How to Balance Conflicting Stakeholder Interests: A Nigerian Project Manager's Guide

Picture this: You’re managing a major infrastructure project in Lagos. Your government sponsor is pushing for an accelerated timeline before their tenure ends, the local community demands more jobs, environmental groups are raising concerns about ecological impact, and the infamous Landlords of Lagos (Omo Onile) are asserting their claims. If you’re a project manager in Nigeria, this scenario might sound all too familiar.

According to PMI, poor stakeholder management is one of the top three causes of project failure. However, with the right strategies, you can successfully navigate these challenges and balance conflicting interests to deliver a successful project.

Laying the Foundation: Understand Your Stakeholders

The success of any project begins with understanding its stakeholders. This requires developing a stakeholder map—a visual tool that helps identify relationships and influence levels. For a typical Nigerian construction project, your map might include government officials, community leaders, funding partners, environmental groups, suppliers, contractors, and, yes, even Omo Onile representatives.

A study by Węgrzyn and Wojewnik-Filipkowska (2022) categorized stakeholders into four groups. Tailoring your engagement strategy to these categories can help manage expectations more effectively:

1. Mixed Blessing Stakeholders: Those who can both help and hinder the project (e.g., government sponsors).
2. Accommodative Stakeholders: Supportive but with low influence (e.g., local suppliers).
3. Non-Supportive Stakeholders: Those opposed to the project (e.g., environmental groups).
4. Marginal Stakeholders: Neither particularly helpful nor harmful (e.g., distant community groups).

Engagement Strategies for Each Stakeholder Type

• Mixed Blessing Stakeholders (e.g., government sponsors):
  
  some text
  • Schedule regular face-to-face meetings to discuss progress.
  • Provide detailed reports on how timelines may impact cost and quality.
  • Involve them in critical decisions to maintain engagement.
• Accommodative Stakeholders (e.g., local suppliers):
  
  some text
  • Send regular project updates.
  • Invite them to milestone celebrations.
  • Acknowledge their contributions in communications.
• Non-Supportive Stakeholders (e.g., environmental groups):
  
  some text
  • Organize town hall meetings to address concerns transparently.
  • Share fact-based information about mitigation measures.
  • Involve them in environmental monitoring efforts.
• Marginal Stakeholders (e.g., distant community groups):
  
  some text
  • Maintain open communication through public updates or notice boards.
  • Be prepared to escalate engagement if their influence grows.

For example, a government sponsor categorized as a “mixed blessing” stakeholder might push for an accelerated timeline, risking quality or safety. A project manager can collaborate closely, providing transparent progress reports and joint problem-solving sessions to balance speed with quality.

Similarly, engaging with the local community—a potentially “non-supportive” stakeholder—requires organizing town hall meetings and involving representatives in monitoring environmental safeguards. This proactive approach builds trust and mitigates resistance.

‍

‍

Communication: The Key to Stakeholder Harmony

Clear and transparent communication fosters trust and ensures all stakeholders remain aligned. A great example is the Eko Atlantic City project, where regular town hall meetings and progress updates kept all parties informed.

Actionable Communication Strategies

1. Schedule Regular Updates: Bi-weekly status reports ensure stakeholders stay informed.
2. Leverage WhatsApp Groups: In Nigeria, this popular tool facilitates quick and informal updates.
3. Host Monthly Meetings: Face-to-face meetings with key stakeholders strengthen relationships and provide clarity.
4. Use Visual Aids: Share project timelines, vision boards, and infographics to simplify complex information.

By adopting these strategies, you demonstrate transparency, build trust, and maintain stakeholder confidence.

Prioritizing Demands: You Can’t Please Everyone

Not all demands can be met—and that’s okay. Using a priority matrix can help assess the urgency and importance of each request. Prioritize long-term project benefits over short-term inconveniences. For example:

• Urgent and Important: Address immediately (e.g., safety concerns raised by contractors).
• Urgent but Less Important: Delegate or communicate delays (e.g., minor timeline adjustments).
• Important but Not Urgent: Schedule for later (e.g., community job requests).
• Neither Important nor Urgent: Acknowledge but deprioritize.

When stakeholders see their concerns tied to the project’s larger vision, they’re more likely to support the overall goals. Creating a project vision board can visually reinforce these priorities, showing how each interest contributes to success.

Resolving Conflicts the Nigerian Way

In Nigeria, personal relationships play a pivotal role in resolving conflicts. When tensions arise, approach them with empathy and understanding. A shared meal or informal meeting can go a long way in fostering goodwill.

Conflict Resolution Strategies

• Listen Actively: Phrases like, “I understand your concern about…” demonstrate empathy.
• Seek Common Ground: Highlight shared goals or interests.
• Be Transparent: Explain your decisions clearly and provide data when possible.

For instance, in the Lekki Free Trade Zone project, informal dialogue with community leaders helped address tensions, reinforcing trust and collaboration.

Making Tough Decisions: Stand Your Ground

As a project manager, tough decisions are inevitable. Whether it’s rejecting an unrealistic timeline or prioritizing environmental safeguards, stand by your choices with confidence. Document your decision-making process to maintain transparency and accountability.

Pro Tips for Decision-Making:

• Data-Driven Decisions: Use factual evidence to support your stance.
• Communicate Clearly: Explain the rationale behind your choices.
• Anticipate Pushback: Prepare responses to potential objections.

Conclusion: Navigating Stakeholder Interests with Confidence

Balancing conflicting stakeholder interests in Nigeria’s dynamic project landscape requires strategic communication, empathy, and a focus on long-term goals. By categorizing stakeholders, tailoring engagement strategies, and maintaining transparency, you can align diverse interests and deliver successful projects.

Remember, the key lies in understanding stakeholder dynamics, prioritizing effectively, and building strong relationships through clear communication. With these strategies, you’re equipped to tackle even the most complex challenges.

Sign up for our Conflict Resolution and Crisis Management Program to master stakeholder management and ensure project success.